And the point is . . .

April 18, 2007 by barbara

by barbara

I got a big smackdown yesterday. I told some folks that I was very disturbed by the Virginia Tech president's press announcement that the shooter there was an Asian male student. My point was this: What earthly difference does it make whether the shooter was Asian or Caucasian or Martian? Where does race fit into this unless/until it is later proved to be a relevant factor in the killings? More.

I was scolded for inserting a racial element into a highly-charged, tragic situation. Ummm, could I just say that I did not insert the shooter's ethnic origin into the mix? It got there ahead of me. It was suggested to me that the president was likely reading from a police report, where such a description is standard. That he was most likely under immense stress and that we all should cut him some slack. I couldn't agree more. However . . . .

I do concede that promoting a racist agenda almost certainly was not the intention of President Charles Steger. But we are living in a society that is simmering in racist stew, morning, noon and night. So it probably isn't surprising that one of my first thoughts (on the heels of, "Oh, God, no, no, no!") was this: "Please let the shooter be a home-bred white guy and not someone from the Middle East!" Because you and I both know this fractured country would have been off to the races if that had been part of this tragedy.

One reason is that the Bush Republicans have played the fear card so often, for so long, that skin of almost any color other than Aryan white is deeply suspect. Yes, I know what I just said. It is what it is.

Within minutes of President Steger's announcement, there were escalating conversations about the militant nature of Koreans and how they are trained almost from infancy to be tough, yea brutal, militants. The hypothesis that grew quickly out of that was that the man we now know to be Cho Seung-Hui was a product of that warrior society. Likely they were thinking North Korea, but I'm not sure of that. And it's a fine point at best. Turns out Cho lived here for fifteen years, legally, which means he was roughly 8 years old when he arrived in the United States. Was he whole and sane then? We may never know. But chances are he was labeled "Korean" first and "child" last.

Make no mistake. I am not in any way defending Cho. Far from it. But we have gotten into some deplorable habits in this country of saying things, even in an offhand, police blotter way, that trigger stereotyping right off the bat. And this is a classic case in point. Cho was a person who had major, ultimately deadly, mental health problems. Didn't matter where he came from originally. Still doesn't.

My guess is that some Koreans did (still do?) wonder what mode of rage will be brought to bear on them. What epithets. What threats. You know the drill. We've seen it before. For starters, Muslims, Mexicans, Japanese, even the French. All of which speaks to a severe problem in our country. It is called racism. Its companion is intolerance. It's a terrifyingly knee-jerk thing.

The toothpaste is out of the tube to stay on this one. Photos of the victims reveal that Cho killed some of "his own." His own what? Fellow human beings? Other males? Student colleagues? Oh. Asians. People of color.

Here is how uncharitable I feel about all of this. I have even wondered if the "Asian male student" descriptor was said intentionally to communicate, "It wasn't a terrorist attack by radical Muslims." But there is no justice in scapegoating an entire region of the world and one nation in particular. And I really do believe that's what happened here. People will not remember Cho's name. I confess I had to go back and look it up. What they will remember is that Korean kid who killed.

There is immense power in language. Some of it is destructive in the extreme. And while the whole matter of Cho's ethnicity is altogether peripheral to the horror of the Virginia Tech massacre, it is tightly linked to it and to the shameful bigotry it reflects.

Posted in


Anonymous (not verified) | April 18, 2007 - 8:09pm

I agree!


Poet (not verified) | April 18, 2007 - 11:52pm

So does Robert Siegel of NPR's "All Things Considered" whose commentary today very nicely reflects on the title of your post.


susan | April 19, 2007 - 12:17am

Here's a slightly different take. At dinner, a friend railed against Virgina Tech for not dismissing such a sick kid from school. She understands that the police could do nothing until an actual threat or assault occured, but why, she asks, did the university allow him to stay enrolled, given behavior that was threatening enough to get him removed from his writing class, and other known mental health issues. What are the policies in higher ed when there is an obviously disturbed student? Do we want schools to be cracking down on the mentally ill? Anyone?


Barbara aka Babs (not verified) | April 19, 2007 - 7:02am

Poet, can you tell me approximately when you heard Siegel's piece? I poked around at NPR, but didn't find it. I'd really like to hear what he has to say about this. Thanks!


barbara aka babs (not verified) | April 19, 2007 - 7:11am

Susan, I've been wondering about this, too. Talk about the proverbial rock and hard place situation. No crime, no arrest. And what is the tipping point for raising concern about someone's behavior, attitude, etc.? When does someone like Cho perceive genuine concern as something malignant, which then sets him off? In addition to being a major safety issue, this also presents a moral dilemma. When is intervention appropriate and how far to go when there is apparent or obvious mental illness? Virginia Tech is going to get roasted for keeping him there, I suppose. But what else could they have done, I wonder?


Poet (not verified) | April 19, 2007 - 7:01pm

Hi Babs--

I am not surprised you couldn't find it because it was not so clearly labeled as a Robert Siegel piece or commentary but if you go to:

that will get you to his coments.


Barbara aka Babs (not verified) | April 20, 2007 - 2:26pm

Hey, thanks for the link, Poet. I now have heard Siegel's piece. He took it a step further and made a case for the fact that Cho acted more out of his American than Korean experience. Sobering, because as I noted, some folks early on were citing the militant nature of Korean governance. And what really happened is a reminder about mental illness, of course, and also that the good old U.S. of A. is one of the most violence-fueled societies on the planet, Iraqi civil war notwithstanding. Uffdah.


jackier (not verified) | August 19, 2008 - 6:27am

Hammer Storage, a division of Bell Microproducts, has released a new line of network storage devices based on Zetera’s Z-SAN SoIP (Storage-over-IP) technology. The storage devices are 4-bay configurations, which are available as either desktop (Z-Box Model HZD4B) or 1U rackmount (Z-Rack Model HZR1U) enclosures. Targeted at the small to medium-sized business storage market, the Z-Series line offers an economical approach to SAN storage. IP is the only storage fabric used, eliminating the requirement for host bus adapters, TCP offload engines, dedicated switches, and RAID controllers. wow goldworld of warcraft goldbuy wow goldcheap wow goldwow power levelingwow powerlevelingwow goldworld of warcraft goldbuy wow goldcheap wow goldwow power levelingwow powerlevelingwow goldworld of warcraft goldbuy wow goldcheap wow goldwow power levelingwow powerlevelingThe Z-SAN architecture affords solution providers an inexpensive, fast, scalable storage alternative. The rackmount version is particularly well-suited for use with Exchange, SQL, backup, video surveillance, video production, and medical imaging applications. ffxi gilfinal fantasy xi gilmaple story mesosmaplestory mesosmaplestory mesolotro goldlotr goldlord of the ring goldffxi gilfinal fantasy xi gilmaple story mesosmaplestory mesosmaplestory mesoThe desktop configuration lends itself to backup, shared storage, and Web server apps. Administrators can typically install a Hammer device in about 20 minutes. The Z-Series devices appear as local drives, enabling them to be easily mounted on a backup server or serve as a backup source or target devices.lotro goldlotr goldlord of the ring goldlotro goldlotr goldlord of the ring goldmaple story mesosmaplestory mesosmaplestory mesoffxi gilfinal fantasy xi gilrunescape goldrunescape money The configurations can be tuned to expand volume sizes and aggregate over a common switch. The SoIP Z-Series supports file- and volume-sharing and block-level applications on a single device. Volumes and RAID constructs can be built from devices in different physical locations.runescape goldrunescape moneyrunescape goldrunescape moneysilkroad goldbuy silkroad goldsilkroad goldbuy silkroad goldcity of villains infamycov infamywow leveling Private volumes are hidden from view by other clients on the network. Both versions use up to four SATA I or SATA II drives to provide 1TB, 1.6TB, and 2TB configurations, which can scale to 128PB per volume across enclosures (subject to OS restrictions). wow golddofus kamaskamas dofusdofus kamaskamas dofusdofus kamaskamas dofusage of conan goldaoc power levelingage of conan power levelingaoc levelingage of conan goldage of conan goldage of conan goldage of conan goldage of conan goldage of conan goldPerformance of over 10GBps can be achieved across multiple enclosures. Data transfers of up to 80MBps are possible, and both configurations come equipped with a 1GB Ethernet interface. The current release is compatible with Windows 2000/XP/2003. Both configurations are compatible with any IP network and come with a one-year warranty.tibia moneyvanguard goldwow goldwow power levelingwow powerlevelingwow goldwow power levelingwow powerleveling age of conan goldaoc power levelingage of conan power levelingaoc levelingage of conan goldaoc power levelingage of conan power levelingaoc leveling A 9TB version is forthcoming later this year, and Linux support and RAID constructs 0, 1, 0+1, and 10 will be available soon, the company says. While the Iomega 400R Series , the IBM TotalStorage DS300 , age of conan goldaoc goldaoc power levelingage of conan power levelingaoc levelingage conan goldage conan goldage conan goldbuy ffxi gilbuy ffxi gilbuy ffxi gilthe Dell/EMC AX100 , and the Snap Server 4200/4500 all offer competitive alternatives, the Hammer Z-Series product line is a simple, economical, scalable, high-performing leader.